Blog

when to go ahead and call HR

There are always going to be times when you feel like all of the pressure is on you. Sometimes it is, but when it comes to making big decisions for your team, you really do have another partner: Human Resources.

Many people shrink back from HR because they get a bad rap. They can turn your world upside-down when you’re least expecting it if you bring something to the department’s attention without strategy (and it happens to the best of us). There are countless TikToks about how HR isn’t your friend, and that’s not necessarily untrue, particularly at the individual contributor level. What else is true is that they exist to protect the business. In leadership, you are part of that running machine; in other words, they also protect you from yourself.

HR shouldn’t be an entity you entirely avoid. Employers often bring their managers the tough stuff. How often do we feel overwhelmed because we just don’t know what the right answer is? Let’s work through a list of scenarios when the right thing to do really is just pick up the phone instead of getting defensive and trying to look smart, or lay down the law.

1. The “Minor Conflict” That Isn’t Minor

Over time, you’ll have members on your team who just don’t mesh. You might think It’s just two personalities clashing. I’ll let them work it out. There’s something to be said for letting adults work out their own problems, but it’s important not to be so disconnected from your floor that you miss some bigger warning signs; remember, as the leader you typically only see what’s on the surface. If they’re acting that way in front of you, what’s going on when you’re not around?

HR should be involved with:

• Repeated interpersonal complaints
• Claims of bullying, exclusion, intimidation, or hostile behavior
• One employee feeling targeted by another
• Ongoing team tension affecting morale or productivity

What appears to be “drama” can actually be harassment, retaliation, discrimination, or a culture problem. HR can help you document patterns, mediate properly, and protect all parties. If worse comes to worst and it escalates before you get ahead of it, HR will ultimately question why you haven’t been proactive in managing the situation. Don’t put yourself in the hot seat.

2. Performance Problems With Personal Undertones

When someone’s performance drops, it’s tempting to just push harder for better results. Leaders should manage performance, but identifying the root cause is an important piece. If you haven’t set clear expectations, offered thorough training, created an environment with access for the necessary tools for success, or offered consistent feedback, some of those issues may start with you. If you have, then there may be a bigger issue.

HR should be involved with:

• Sudden performance decline from a previously strong employee
• Attendance changes
• Emotional volatility
• Signs of burnout, grief, medical stress, addiction, or crisis

Not every performance issue is a motivation issue; however, if something deeper is at the center, you can dive in and get out of your depth fast. HR can protect you from crossing boundaries that would compromise legal boundaries, violate leave laws, disability laws, or mishandling sensitive circumstances. Where waters run deep, bring the life jacket.

3. The Employee Who “Just Needs To Be Fired”

Every tenured manager has made a hiring mistake and/or inherited someone they wish they hadn’t. You may think It’s obvious. It’s not working out. I’m guilty of that as well! Even if you have documentation, when you’re ready to pull the trigger, getting approval is a key step in keeping your (not to mention the company’s) liability limited.

HR should be involved with:

• Any termination decision
• Final warnings
• Repeated write-ups
• Probationary exits
• Layoffs or restructuring

“If it isn’t documented, it didn’t happen.” Sound familiar? That’s usually what HR says when you don’t have your ducks in a row. If you ask for clearance to terminate and HR finds out there’s no performance or behavioral paper trail, you’re really back at square one. How can you prove any of your complaints? Many managers focus on whether termination feels justified. HR focuses on whether it’s documented, consistent, defensible, and aligned with policy. Being right is not the same as being protected.

4. Accommodation Requests Disguised As Casual Commentary

If you have an employee mentioning a need for flexibility, you can’t put enforceable guidelines around it without an accommodation. It documents the conversation as well as the need, and keeps you and the employee both accountable to the agreement and the expectations.

HR should be involved with:

• Mentions of medical conditions affecting work
• Requests for schedule changes tied to health or family needs
• Statements of struggling due to anxiety, stress, or medication
• Religious scheduling or dress requests

Employees rarely use legal terminology, and often mention needs casually. Leaders who dismiss or ignore those comments can unintentionally create internal liability (i.e. discrimination). Don’t dismiss what’s spoken softly as “the small stuff”.

5. The High Performer Who Breaks Rules

You may think, “They’re difficult, but they produce.” [If you missed my article on managing high performers, check it out here.]

HR should be involved with:

• Top performer with complaints against them
• Boundary violations
• Toxic behavior tolerated because of results
• Team attrition around one “star”
• Policy violations

Protecting revenue at the expense of culture usually costs more money later. Many organizations lose great people because of their commitment to overprotecting one productive one.

6. Pay, Promotion, and Fairness Conversations

People wanting upgrades to their current situation happens with a fair amount of regularity. It might be easier to just promise them something and worry about it later. Usually, though, that puts you on the ropes instead of them.

HR should be involved with:

• Off-cycle raise discussions
• Promotion promises
• Internal equity concerns
• Counteroffers
• Complaints of favoritism

Good intentions can create inconsistent precedent, compensation inequity, or damage trust when promises can’t be fulfilled. Leaders overpromise in private and create organizational debt in public.

7. Anything That Begins With “Don’t Tell Anyone…”

We tell our team members “vent up or out, not down.” That means tell a boss or a peer, but don’t blow smoke down to your team. Sometimes, that venting has more of a message to it than just the complaint. Innocent “venting” about real problems can bring you an obligation to act, and put you at risk if you don’t.

HR should be involved with:

• Harassment allegations
• Safety concerns
• Threatening comments
• Ethics complaints
• Claims involving discrimination or retaliation

Once a leader knows, the company often knows; and, more often than not, as a leader you’re considered “the company”. Silence is not neutrality, and confidentiality is not the same as secrecy. If someone is complaining about conditions where they’re clearly harmed by the environment or its interactions, it’s your duty to escalate. You can handle the anger later. Get help before you become complicit.

8. Reorganizations And Quiet Structural Changes

People agree to specifics when they onboard or accept a new role. You don’t get to just “shift priorities around.” If you do, and an employee hits you with “that’s just not in my job description”, and it ISN’T in their job description, that falls back on… guess who.

HR should be involved with:

• Role redesigns
• Team mergers
• Reporting line changes
• Demotions in disguise
• Significant workload redistribution

Structural moves can affect pay bands, job descriptions, morale, protected classes, and retention risks. Organizational charts serve as legal documents more often than leaders realize.

___

If HR is so great, why do leaders avoid them in the first place? For one, managers want to appear capable. Asking for help can be hard, especially if you’ve acted unethically or have swept things under the rug. People are afraid that HR will slow down processes, create an unwanted paper trail, or escalate mole hills into mountains. People are distrustful of HR practices because when you involve them proactively, you naturally only want it to benefit you. HR can often bring the heat on both sides as an objective observer. The truth, though, is often the escalation happens when you involve HR too late.

Great leaders don’t involve HR because they’re weak or incapable. They involve HR because leadership includes judgment, risk awareness, and stewardship. HR shouldn’t run every conversation, but they shouldn’t be the last to know.

Disclaimer: I have worked for organizations in which bringing concerns to HR has brought me under fire unfairly, and they proposed that advocating for my team members was bait to create an issue where they couldn’t see one. There ARE circumstances where HR may not give the attention that’s needed. If this is the case in your workplace, be sure to document issues 1., as they arise, and 2., to your direct-line leadership. This will create the necessary pattern needed to protect you against further internal allegations or from claims declaring a lack of action. Encourage your team members to approach HR directly to remove yourself as a middle man. HR can’t negate a claim directly from the source.

Head over to my Leadership Consulting page to learn more about working together!